Waiver of Diplomatic Immunity Must Be Express
In a rolled up hearing for permission to apply for judicial review (JR) and the substantive merits, the parents of Harry Dunn challenged a determination that Mrs S enjoyed diplomatic immunity: The Queen (on the Application of Charlotte Charles and Tim Dunn) v The Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs and Chief Constable of Northamptonshire Police (Interested Party) [2020] EWHC 3185 (Admin) Flaux LJ and Saini J.
They also alleged, secondly, that the Foreign & Commonwealth Office (FCO) unlawfully confirmed and/or advised the relevant police force that Mrs S had immunity from criminal jurisdiction and/or obstructed a criminal investigation.
Thirdly, they claimed that these acts breached Art.2 of the European Convention of Human Rights.
Permission to apply for JR was refused on grounds two and three on the basis that they were not arguable.
Nineteen-year-old Harry Dunn was killed following a collision between his motorbike and a vehicle driven by Mrs S on 27 August 2019.
The evidence strongly suggested that Mrs S, wife of JS, a member of the United States Government’s Administrative and Technical Staff at RAF Croughton, was driving on the wrong side of the road at the time of the accident.
There was a period of dialogue between the US Embassy and the FCO concerning potential diplomatic immunity from criminal jurisdiction in the United Kingdom.
On 15 September 2019 Mrs S left England, the FCO having accepted that she was entitled to such immunity after a challenge from the US Embassy.
Extradition proceedings were commenced by the CPS on 22 December 2019.
An extradition request was submitted on 10 January 2020 but the US State Department declined to progress the extradition.
As explained by Lord Sumption in Al-Malki v Reyes [2017] UKSC 61, [2019] AC735, the legal immunity of diplomatic agents “is one of the oldest principles of customary international law.”
The law was codified in the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations (VCDR), to which over 190 States are parties.
The VCDR had been implemented, in part, by the Diplomatic Privileges Act 1964, s2(1) of which provided that the articles of the VCDR shall have the force of law in the United Kingdom.
Art.31(1) VCDR provides: A diplomatic agent shall enjoy immunity from the criminal jurisdiction of the receiving State … Art.31(2) provides: A diplomatic agent is not obliged to give evidence as a witness.
Immunity from jurisdiction of diplomatic agents and of persons enjoying immunity under Art.37 may be waived by the sending State: Art.32(1).
Crucially, Waiver must always be express: Art 32(2)
Of further note, Art.37(1) states: The members of the family of a diplomatic agent forming part of his household shall, if they are not nationals of the receiving State, enjoy the privileges and immunities specified in Arts.29 to 36.
The arrangements by which members of the US Embassy were first based at RAF Croughton were agreed between the UK and US in an Exchange of Notes in 1994.
On 15 August 1995, a Home Office Minister at the FCO sent to the US Ambassador a letter noting that a large number of non-diplomatic staff were to be based a considerable distance from the Embassy itself.
It said that HM Government would be willing to accept referenced persons “on the understanding that the United States Government by its reply to this letter waives the immunity from criminal jurisdiction of these employees in respect of acts performed outside the course of their duties.”
On 17 August 1995 the US Ambassador replied: “We do accept the conditions regarding criminal immunity for the … members of the Croughton facility who will have A&T status.”
By a further exchange of letters, it was agreed that the Regional Information Technical Centre in Croughton was to be considered diplomatic premises.
Although permission to apply for judicial review on the first ground was permitted, the claim was dismissed. The Court’s judgment was that Mrs S had immunity at the time of Harry’s death.
The issue of immunity needed to be approached in the context of the VCDR to which the authors of the Exchange of Notes made repeated and express reference. It was the framework within which the US and UK were corresponding.
The broad reasons for reaching the conclusion that Mrs S enjoyed immunity were:
- Mr S was appointed by the US as a member of A&T Staff pursuant to the exercise of its right under Art.7 VCDR. Notification of the appointment along with details of family members was provided to the FCO.
- By operation of Arts 37(2) and 39 VCDR, Mr S and his family members (including Mrs S) enjoyed the privileges and immunities specified in Arts.29-35 VCDR on arrival in the UK. These were rights she had acquired under primary domestic legislation.
- The privileges and immunities afforded to Mr and Mrs S derived from the VCDR and the 1964 Act, not from the Exchange of Notes, and followed from the US’s appointment of Mr S.
- Those immunities were enjoyed in full by Mr S and his family subject only to any valid waiver consistent with Art. 32 of the VCDR.
- The only such valid VCDR compliant waiver was to be found in the Exchange Notes which included limited pre-waiver of Mr S’s immunity from criminal jurisdiction.
- It was common ground that as regards Mrs S there was no Art.32(1) compliant waiver.
In order for there to have been a waiver of Mrs S’s immunity (an entitlement she held on arrival), the machinery of Art 32 of the VCDR had to be employed and that required an express or later waiver.
The Court added that it did not come to this conclusion with any enthusiasm for the result, but it was compelled by the operation of the VCDR.
It will be clear to anyone who reads the full judgment in this case that the FCO did not understand its own agreement.
It considered that despite the express wording in the Exchange of Notes, the waiver of immunity also applied to family members. They soon had to concede that was wrong.
We shall never know the original intention, but the Court could only give effect to the express words.

