skip to Main Content

Anonymous Surrogacy: Requirements for a Parental Order

The President of the Family Division examined the individual requirements for a parental order set out in s54 of the Human Fertilisation & Embryology Act 2008, each of which must be satisfied before the court could grant a parenting order: H, Re (Anonymous Surrogacy) [2025] EWHC 220 (Fam)  Sir Andrew MacFarlane P

The court must scrutinise parental order applications with care to ensure compliance with the statute, particularly so when the application included a foreign element.

The application concerned baby girl A who was now aged nearly two years. The applicants, anonymously randomised as Mr and Mrs H, were of Nigerian descent. Mrs H, a Nigerian national, had leave to remain in the UK. The couple had been married for 8 years. They embarked on a surrogacy arrangement through a clinic in Nigeria which eventually resulted in A’s birth. DNA testing confirmed that Mr H was A’s biological father. Although the situation was not entirely clear, the implication was that A’s biological mother was the surrogate mother.

The difficulty in the case was that the surrogate was anonymous and her identity was unknown. Before a court may grant a parental order, it must be satisfied that the surrogate mother agrees unconditionally to the making of the order unless the surrogate mother could not be found or was incapable of giving agreement. The focus of the judgment was on the court’s approach to such a case, where the identity of the surrogate was simply unknown.

With respect to Nigeria, it was to be noted that the UK had imposed special restrictions on adoptions from that country (Special Restrictions on Adoptions from Abroad (Nigeria) Order 2021). Guidance issued by the Department of Education  listed the specific areas of concern relating to adoption from Nigeria as including difficulties confirming the background and adoptability of children, unreliable documentation, concerns about corruption in the Nigerian adoption system; evidence of organised child trafficking within Nigeria and concerns about weaknesses in checks completed by Nigerian authorities in relation to adoption applications from prospective adopters who were habitually resident in the United Kingdom and therefore likely to in fact be intended to be intercountry adoptions.

A further cause for concern in the present case was the anonymity of the surrogate mother. Not only did anonymity prevent the court from being able to be satisfied that the mother knew of the application and consented to it, it also raised the level of suspicion that the arrangement may have been otherwise than it was said to be. Whilst Mr and Mrs H had explained their motivation for opting for an anonymous surrogacy, their decision had, in fact, caused them a great deal of difficulty in presenting the present application. Those who followed in their footsteps in the future would be well advised to avoid engaging with an anonymous surrogate.

But having now received pieces of information and evidence from Mr and Mrs H, bit by bit, over a series of hearings and, particularly having now at last seen the purported surrogacy agreement, the court was in a position to determine the application.

On the balance of probability, on the basis of the material that had now been filed and on the basis of the insightful reports of the allocated Parental Order Reporter, his Lordship was satisfied that Mr and Mrs H did enter into a surrogacy arrangement with the Lifelink Fertility Clinic in Nigeria. He was also satisfied that Mr H was A’s genetic father and that the surrogate mother was a woman known only as “OS” in the agreement. She was probably the person whose identity details were shown to the Parental Order Reporter. The prospects of tracing her and securing her engagement with the proceedings were so remote as to hold that the reality was that she “cannot be found”. Section 54(7) HFEA 2008 was therefore satisfied on that basis with the consequence that the application could proceed without the need to obtain her agreement under s54(6).

On that basis, the court had jurisdiction to make a parental order. To do so was manifestly in the best interests of A. She was being well cared for by the only two people she had ever known as her mother and father. She would in any event continue to be brought up in their care. Now that the statutory criteria had been met, A’s welfare required that a parental order be made so that, henceforward, Mr and Mrs H would dbe her parents in law.

The court therefore directed that a parental order be issued in favour of Mr and Mrs H with respect to A.

 

 

Back To Top