skip to Main Content

Health Protection: Dangerous Unofficial Guidance

The Health Protection Regulations (Coronavirus Restrictions) (England) Regulations 2020 may be a temporary restriction of our liberty which we have to endure, but unofficial guidance in whatever form is unhelpful and dangerous in the wrong hands.

Restrictions on movement create a curfew subject to exceptions. Regulation 6(1) provides that no person may leave the place where they are living without reasonable excuse and 6(2) sets out what ‘reasonable excuse’ includes.   In summary, it includes the need to obtain basic necessities, to take exercise alone or with other members of their household, to seek medical assistance, to travel for the purposes of work, to attend a funeral (in certain circumstances), and a number of others which it is not necessary to expound for the purposes of this blog.

The regulations had barely been laid before parliament before some journalist (no doubt looking for tomorrow’s headline) asked Michael Gove what would be a reasonable period of exercise and the Minister responded that he thought 30 minutes or an hour would be reasonable. That flashed around the country as if it were a new rule of law, but that is not what the regulation says. It says ‘to take exercise either alone or with other members of their household’. One could exercise outside all day without contravening the regulation. There have been other questions raised with Ministers which have produced equally off-the-cuff responses which journalists have seized on for their stories, but no single ministerial response has the force of law.

The distinguished former Supreme Court Justice, Lord Sumption, has written that the police have no powers to enforce ministers’ wishes but only legal regulations and that the public should not be ‘resigning their liberty’ to over-zealous citizens in uniform. The police’s job is to enforce the letter of the law and not what they conceive to be the appropriate moral standpoint (or that of other members of the public).

Now, to make matters worse, the BBC reports that the National Police Chiefs’ Council (NPCC) and the College of Policing have issued their own guidance to officers as to what is likely to be a ‘reasonable excuse’ to someone to leave their home, and it is suggested that it is guidance drawn from guidelines issued by the Crown Prosecution Service. For example, under the guidance police are advised not to intervene if people stop to rest or eat lunch while on a long walk, but short walks to sit on a park bench are not allowed. On exercise, the guidance lists driving to the countryside for a walk as reasonable if more time is spent walking than driving. It adds that driving for a prolonged period with only brief exercise is not reasonable. A very short period of exercise to excuse a long period of inactivity may mean that the person is not engaged in exercise.

None of that so called guidance is necessary because the regulations themselves lay down precisely what is and what is not permitted, but the the guidance does not have the force of law.

Many members of the public are in fear of the consequences of this unknown virus and many of our front line services are working under stress and in dangerous conditions. It is right that we respect that, respect each other’s boundaries and comply with the regulations.

But it is not right that individual ministers, police officers or their representative bodies seek to expand those regulations. The government has enacted emergency legislation. It is necessary for present purposes but it impinges upon freedoms for which many of our forebears fought, and for which some gave their lives. The legislation should be interpreted strictly and where there is doubt the citizen must have the benefit of that doubt.

Rarely has there been a greater need for a vigilant legal profession to stand up for the rights of citizens in these circumstances, and for very careful judicial scrutiny of cases brought before the courts.

Back To Top