skip to Main Content

Healthcare Regulation: Insufficient Public Protection

More than ten years ago around two hundred dusty files relating to complaints from members of the public and other service users about certain healthcare professionals were discovered in a locked cupboard at one of the regulator’s offices.

Nothing had been done to action the complaints and senior management was, until then, blissfully unaware of them.

The Chief Executive of that organisation was subsequently suspended at the government’s prompting, faced a disciplinary procedure and dismissed.

That organisation never recovered, change was too slow to arrive and, two or three years later, the regulator was abolished as part of a ministerial bonfire of quangos.

Most regulators though work diligently to pursue their investigations efficiently whilst struggling against archaic structures unchangeable without parliamentary approval (which usually takes years) .

There is no doubt that their task is difficult and the investigations often protracted because of  challenges in obtaining information, through other organisations’ bureaucratic procedures, or the more general problem of obtaining cogent information to support the process.

Reform of healthcare regulation is long overdue.

The government has now put forward proposals for reform and is consulting upon them.  A large number of those proposals are to be welcomed.

But the Professional Standards Authority (PSA), whose primary job is to protect the public by improving regulation and reviewing the performance of regulators, rightly has concerns.

The PSA has long supported proportionate, consistent and targeted regulation, and banged the drum of transparency, accountability and agility, all the while placing public protection at the heart of everything it does.

It recognises that proposals to reduce stress and time for all parties involved in the fitness to practise process are at the top of its regulatory reform list.  At the same time, it should not result in a reduction in public protection, fairness and transparency.

The government’s proposed accepted outcomes deals with concerns about professionals without the need for a public hearing as a result of an agreement between the healthcare professional and the regulator.

At first sight, this is a step forward as it will speed up the process and, at the same time, reduce the stress on complainants, witnesses and the professional.

The gaping hole in the proposal is that it does not have at its heart the fundamental principle of public protection because there is no proposal for an independent body, such as the PSA, to challenge any outcomes that may be regarded as unsafe.

Instead the proposal is that anyone may ask for a review.  Undoubtedly, that would be down to the patient or other service user.  What then?  The regulator itself would make the final decision rather than the court, as is now the case – prosecutor, judge, jury and final court of appeal in its own cause.

Under the existing system the PSA has legislative power to challenge final decisions about the conduct or competence of health professionals if they are deemed to be insufficient to protect the public.

It is a power that is used cautiously, probably no more than 20 times in a year, but 90% of the appeals that the PSA takes to the High Court are successful. Those successes strengthen public protection.

There have been cases where sexual predators and abusers of vulnerable patients have been permitted to remain on the register with insufficient sanction, but the PSA has successfully argued before the High Court that such conduct is incompatible with continued registration.

The PSA’s oversight is critical for all aspects of fitness to practise investigations: it ensures that cases are not closed by a regulator before they are investigated, it oversees the efficient progress of the investigation and it reviews the outcomes.  This is all essential for public protection.

Furthermore, knowing that they are liable to be called to account and are open to inspection, keeps the regulators on their toes.  They are less likely to slip into the shoddy practices of yesteryear where some complaints seem to disappear down deep dark holes never to be seen again.

Let the government have your views on its proposals: www.gov.uk/government/consultations/regulating-healthcare-professionals-protecting-the-public

 

 

 

 

Back To Top