Justiciable, Unlawful, Void and of No effect
Justiciable, unlawful, void and of no effect was the Prime Minister’s advice to the Queen to prorogue parliament. So ruled a unanimous 11 panel member of the UK’s Supreme Court today in R (on the application of Miller) v The Prime Minister, and Cherry and others v Advocate General for Scotland [2019] UKSC 41, thus upholding the decision of Scotland’s Court of Session (Inner House) and overruling the English Divisional Court.
Holding, firstly, that the lawfulness of the Prime Minister’s advice to Her Majesty was justiciable, the court found that courts had exercised a supervisory jurisdiction over the lawfulness of acts of the Government for centuries, adding that as long ago as 1611 the court held that ‘the King [who was then the government] hath no prerogative but that which the law of the land allows him.’ It was, however, necessary to distinguish between two different questions: (1) whether a prerogative power existed and (2) if so, its extent. All parties had accepted in this case that the court had jurisdiction to decide upon the existence and limits of a prerogative power.
For present purposes, the relevant limit on the power to prorogue was that a decision to advise the monarch to prorogue would be unlawful if it had the effect of frustrating or preventing, without reasonable justification, the ability of Parliament to carry out its constitutional function as a legislature and as the body responsible for the supervision of the executive. If prorogation had that effect, there was no need to consider whether the Prime Minister’s motive or purpose was unlawful.
This was not, the court observed, a normal prorogation in the run-up to a Queen’s Speech; it prevented Parliament from carrying out its constitutional role for five out of the possible eight weeks between the end of the summer recess and exit (should we say ‘Brexit’) day on 31 October, a day on which fundamental change was due to take place in the Constitution of the United Kingdom. Parliament, and in particular, the House of Commons as the elected representatives of the people had a right to a voice in how that change came about. The effect upon the fundamentals of our democracy was extreme.
No justification for taking action with such extreme effect had been put before the court, and the court was therefore bound to consider the decision to advise Her Majesty to prorogue was unlawful because it had the effect of frustrating or preventing the ability of Parliament to carry out its constitutional function without reasonable justification.
The court’s conclusion that the Prime Minister’s advice was unlawful, void and of no effect meant that the Order in Council to which it led was also unlawful, void and of no effect and should be quashed. Parliament had not been prorogued. It was for Parliament, and in particular the Speaker and Lord Speaker, to decide what to do next and they could take immediate steps to enable each House to meet as soon as possible.
But a few days ago I stuck my neck out in a blog post on this website (‘A Slippery Political-Legal Slope) and suggested in rather strident terms that the Court of Session (Inner House) was incorrect and had addressed the wrong question. But the Supreme Court has upheld that decision. The trouble with sticking one’s neck out is that one is liable to have one’s head chopped off! That is the joy of being a lawyer.
This was a resounding and unanimous decision from as strong a Supreme Court as one is likely to see. There are no dissenting judgments on which the aggrieved can pin their counter-arguments.
It is perhaps what the fictional Sir Humphrey would call a ‘courageous decision’. The judges have not hesitated to go where, as I suggested in that earlier blog post, angels may fear to tread. I applaud their united courage in expressing the law as they find it to be, and I sincerely hope that history judges them to have trodden the correct side of a very fine line.

