Refusal to Adjourn Child’s Life and Death Decision
10 September 2022 (Judgment 9 September 2022)
A judge was wrong, ruled the Court of Appeal, when he refused to grant the parents an adjournment of a hearing when the issue before the court was the gravest and most important matter any parent could every face, the life and death of a child: Re A (A Child) (Withdrawal of Treatment: Legal Representation) 2022 EWCA Civ 1221.pdf (judiciary.uk): Singh, Baker, Phillips LJJ
The tragic case concerned a small baby, born in April 2022, who was being kept alive on a ventilator after sustaining devastating brain injuries. Medical opinion of the treating clinicians was that there was no hope of any recovery, that he was dying, his condition was rapidly deteriorating and it was proving difficult to treat him.
The NHS Trust applied at a hearing before Hayden J on 25 August for permission to withdraw treatment. The parents were unrepresented, the judge refused an application to adjourn to allow them to be represented and, the following day made the order sought.
At earlier stages in the proceedings the parents had been represented but legal aid funding was withdrawn. The solicitors endeavoured to find alternative funding but a few days before the hearing said they would be unable to act. The parents had only three days before the hearing to find other representation or prepare to conduct the hearing themselves.
The parents had a strong argument having lost their legal representation only a few days before the hearing through no fault of their own. The task they faced was daunting because the preparation and conduct of cross-examination in these cases, which involved complex medical evidence and voluminous medical records, and the preparation and presentation of legal argument were difficult tasks even for an experienced lawyer.
This was at a time when their child was lying desperately ill in hospital. These points were arguments in favour of the judge granting a short adjournment. The fact that on paper the medical evidence all seemed to point one way did not mean that the parents should not have an opportunity to challenge it. Earlier in the case the treating clinicians had declared A dead on the basis of several brain stem tests only to rescind the declaration when he started breathing again.
The Supreme Court had stressed in recent years that the Human Rights Act 1998 should not normally be treated as the starting point in any case in which human rights issues arose. Although its importance was unquestionable, it did not supersede the protection of human rights under the common law or statute or create a discrete body of law based on the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights.
As Lord reed pointed out[1], the guarantee of a fair trial under Article 6 was fulfilled primarily through detailed rules and principles to be found in several areas of domestic law, including the law of evidence and procedure, administrative law and the law relating to legal aid.
There were at least two fundamental reasons why procedural fairness was important. The first was that it helped to improve the chances of reaching the right result but it included, secondly, the avoidance of the feelings of resentment which would arise if a person was unable to participate effectively in a decision-making process which affected them. In this way the law sought to protect the value of human dignity.
The Court reached the conclusion to set aside judgment by applying common law principles of fairness. The key proposition was that expressed by McFarlane LJ[2]: “It therefore seems to me that issues such as the one raised in the present case will of necessity be fact specific; it will be necessary to look at all of the elements that were in play before the judge who decided to adjourn or not adjourn a set of proceedings.”
Looking at the specific facts of the case, the judge seemingly did not have regard to a number of the elements relevant to the decision to adjourn, and the application would therefore be relisted before another judge at the earliest opportunity.
[1] R (Osborn) v Parole Board [2013] UKSC 61; [2014] AC 1115, at paragraphs 54-63
[2] Re G-B (Children) [2013] EWCA Civ 164 at para 49
This article has been provided free of charge. Please consider becoming a paying subscriber to Baines Law Regulatory, a living topic-based reference work for those interested in or practising regulatory and disciplinary law. The subscription includes access to a Table of Cases most of which are hyperlinked to the judgments.
There is a free 7 day trial. The cost is £12.00 per month (inc VAT) or a discounted £120.00 per year (inc VAT). These charges are discounted by 50% for law students, trainees/bar pupils and Junior ARDL members.

