skip to Main Content

Roman Abramovich was Defamed

Statements in a book entitled Putin’s People: How the KGB Took Back Russia and Then Took on the West were the subject of a libel action arising out of its publication and held by the High Court to be defamatory of the Claimant: Roman Abramovich v (1) Harper Collins Publishers Limited (2) Catherine Belton [2021] EWHC 3154 (QB): Mrs Justice Tipples

The dust cover of the book included a quote from the author of Moneyland which read: “This is the Putin Book that we’ve been waiting for.”

The principles to be applied to determine whether a statement complained of contained allegations of fact or opinion were summarised in Koutsogiannis v The Random House Group Ltd[1] and Corbyn v Millett [2021][2] and were well-known:

“… when determining whether the words complained of contain allegations of fact or opinion, the court will be guided by the following points:

  • The statement must be recognisable as comment, as distinct from imputation of fact.
  • Opinion is something which is or can be reasonably be inferred to be a deduction, inference, conclusion, criticism, remark, observation etc.
  • The ultimate question is how the words would strike the ordinary reasonable reader. The subject matter and context of the words may be an important indicator of whether they are fact or opinion.
  • Some statements which are, by their nature and appearance opinion, are nevertheless treated as statements of fact where, for instance, the opinion implies that a claimant has done something but does not indicate what that something is, ie the statement is a bare comment.
  • Whether an allegation that someone has acted “dishonestly” or “criminally” is an allegation of fact or expression of opinion will very much depend on context. There is no fixed rule that a statement that someone has been dishonest must be treated as an allegation of fact.”

The judge concluded that the natural and ordinary meanings of the words complained of, read in their proper context as they affected the claimant were:

  • The claimant was under the control of President Vladimir Putin and, on the directions of President Putin and the Kremlin, he had to make his fortune from his business empire available for the use of President Putin and his regime. The claimant had had little choice but to comply with those direction because, if he had not done so, he would have lost his wealth to the Russian state and could have been exiled or jailed.
  • Further to that relationship (a) the claimant invested $2.5 billion of his own fortune in Chukotka, a remote region in Russia; (b) the claimant purchased Chelsea Football Club in 2003 at the direction of President Putin so that Russia could gain acceptance and influence in the UK; (c) the claimant split the majority of $13 billion cash he received from the sale of Sibneft to Gazprom with the associates of President Putin; (d) The claimant purchased about $300 million of shares in Rosneft at the direction of the Kremlin so that the initial public offering would not fail; and (e) The claimant moved to New York at the direction of President Putin so that Russian could influence the family of Donald Trump.
  • The claimant donated $203 million to Petromed, a company purchasing medical equipment but money paid in this way was transferred out of Russia through a web of offshore companies and used to fund Bank Rossiya’s rapid expansion.
  • The Kremlin was behind a claim by Mr Berezovsky when he sued the claimant in London’s High Court for $6.5 billion, and the claimant won because he ran a false case denying that Mr Berezovsky had ever owned certain assets.
  • The claimant acted as the cashier to the former Russian President Boris Yeltsin and his family providing them with money from his own business empire to use for their own private purposes.

The judge disagreed with the defendants that the reasons why the claimant had made the fortune from his business empire available for the use of President Putin and his regime, purchased Chelsea Football Club, invested in Rosneft and moved to New York were statements of opinion.

Those reasons were verifiable as facts, and that is how the words would strike the ordinary reasonable read.  The statements complained of were all statements of fact.

 

 

[1] [2020] 4 WLR 25, Nicklin J

[2] [2021] EWCA Civ 567

Back To Top