skip to Main Content

Solicitor Substituted Own Judgment for Court Order

20 February 2023

A decision of the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal which found allegations of mismanagement of some aspects of the business of two clients resulting in a fine of £8,000 and costs, was challenged by the solicitor who had elected not to give evidence in the SDT proceedings: Lone v Solicitors Regulation Authority Ltd [2023] EWHC 349 (Admin) Collins Rice J

The solicitor was a sole practitioner at the firm of Attiyah Lone & Associates. He acted in divorce proceedings for a client and obtained a third party order for recovery of fees.  The court ordered, on an interim basis, that his client’s share of net proceeds of property was to be paid to Attiyah Lone subject to the following: the undisputed amount of £29,000 was to be paid to the solicitor’s firm into office account as pre-payment of outstanding legal fees, with the balance being held in his firm’s client account until further order or written agreement.

By the time the property sales were completed, Attiyah Lone had found itself unable to obtain new professional indemnity insurance cover and had to close. The solicitor set up a new firm, AL Law, which was authorised by the SRA but by the time the proceeds of the property sales came through AL Law did not yet have a client account.

The solicitor therefore initiated a series of transactions having the effect of placing £29,000 into his office account and the balance into the client account of another solicitors firm, firm B. The SRA intervened into firm B (person B eventually being struck off) and charged the solicitor with acting improperly in respect of dealing with monies in which his client had an interest.

Further charges were subsequently brought against the solicitor for allowing person B to work on a client’s matter when he held over £43,000 belonging to that client, and that he failed to register a legal charge over person B’s property.

Her Ladyship said that the solicitor did not comply with an order of the court. She found no basis for impugning the Tribunal’s evident starting point that that, in and of itself, was a matter of impropriety. The Tribunal took full account of the solicitor’s predicament, acknowledged on the face of the decision, and understood the problem he faced in complying as directed, but it found he had no legal entitlement to make the arrangements he did. There was no error of law in the Tribunal’s conclusion that the breach of the court order and the substitution by the solicitor of his own judgment for that of the court as to the protection of the competing interests in the money was improper.

In respect of the other matters, the solicitor had an alternative. Beyond handover, and indeed not excluding handover, he could have consulted and worked with the intervention agent rather than continuing to involve person B. Interventions in solicitors’ firms were made for a reason and were designed in detail to operate for the full protection of clients and former clients of the intervened firm.

In a situation where the solicitor assumed professional responsibility for administering an estate and of duties to client D, when she became his client, he had a specific duty to protect this estate money from person B’s conflicted interests. He could have been expected either to take such steps as were available to him to secure the loan or to obtain and record in the clearest possible terms and agreement between the parties to do something different. On the evidence, the Tribunal found he did neither.

The solicitor felt strongly that he had been shabbily treated, if not victimised, by the regulatory proceedings that were brought against him. He felt that in the matters with which he had been charged – all of which were raised as a byproduct of the SRA intervention into firm B – he had acted with integrity and worked hard and imaginatively to get the best results for his clients in difficult situations. He was even more offended to have been landed with an ‘eye watering’ costs bill of £29,359.05 as a result.

The Tribunal throughout acknowledged the solicitor’s good faith and good intentions. No client had lost money. It noted his unblemished record and had no reservations about his future practice. But it identified three points of professional misjudgment which it assessed relatively (but not ‘very’) seriously because they involved breach of a court order and a degree of inattentiveness to the inherent problems of conflict of interest, both of which went to the fundamentals of the legal profession and to the public’s confidence in it. In each case he was found to have substituted his own solution to the management of risk for that which was, for good reason, professionally indicated.

The Court could not see that the Tribunal went wrong in law, made unsupported findings, or made discretionary and evaluative decisions that were off the scale of choices properly available to it. The appeal was dismissed.

 

 

Back To Top