The Meaning of Dwelling
Although in most cases it is obvious if a building is a dwelling, it fell to the Court of Appeal to determine whether, in the instant case, the burglary of a hotel room was the burglary of a dwelling: Bruce Chipunza v Regina [2021] EWCA Crim 597: Thirlwall LJ, Kerr and Freedman JJ
Declining, in an earlier case, to give guidance on the issue[1] the appeal court had said that in an appropriate case it would be a matter for a jury to determine, and the directions given by the judge could, if appropriate, be considered on appeal. It was largely a question of fact in each individual case which the jury would have to decide.
The Divisional Court held on an another appeal by way of case stated[2] that current use as such was not necessary for a building to be a dwelling; it was a matter of fact and degree.
The reference in that judgment to the fact that a hotel had been found to be a dwelling in a different case[3] was a misreading of the decision. In that case the appellant had pleaded guilty to the burglary of two hotel rooms, not to burglary of a dwelling.
The words ‘dwell’ and ‘dwelling’ were not terms of art with a specialised legal meaning. They were ordinary English words, even if perhaps no longer in common use. They “refer to where one lives and makes one’s home”.[4]
They suggested a greater degree of settled occupation than ‘reside’ and ‘residence’, connoting the place where the occupier habitually slept and usually ate, but the idea that s/he must also cook meals there was found only in the law reports. It found no support in English literature.
Houses and flats were generally built to be lived in, to be used as dwellings. Hotels were not generally built to be used as dwellings; their commercial function was to provide a temporary place to stay.
The Court was satisfied that the judge could and should have explained to the jury what a dwelling was. It would have been sufficient to say a dwelling was a building or part of a building in which a person was living and made his/her/their home.
The most usual examples of dwellings were houses and flats in which people lived and made their homes. Other buildings or parts of buildings may be dwellings.
This should have been followed by a list of features which the jury may have considered pointed towards or away from the room being a dwelling.
The most striking feature which pointed away from the hotel room being a dwelling was the transient nature of the hotel guest’s occupation of it. She had arrived the previous evening, intending to stay for three nights.
In the Court’s judgment, the judge was bound to invite the jury to consider whether such occupation was consistent with the room being a dwelling rather than simply a place to say when working away from home.
Other factors which pointed away from the hotel room being a dwelling were these: the guest’s home address was in Birmingham; she referred to ‘staying’ in hotels, rather than living there; she stayed in different rooms in different hotels every week; she had no control over which room she had or even which hotel she stayed in (this was determined by all hotels); check-in and check-out times were determined by the hotel as 2pm and 12 pm respectively; she had no control over who went into the room when she was not there; hotel employees had a master key; she was bound by the rules of the hotel as to smoking, fire drills and so on; she had no choice over the décor or furniture in the hotel room.
Some of those points would be less important in a case where a person was living in a hotel, using it as their home, receiving mail there. They were nonetheless relevant factors in determining whether, in the absence of any settled occupation, the hotel room was a dwelling.
The judge told the jury on a number of occasions that the decision about whether the room was a dwelling was a matter for them, but the failure to put before them a balanced account of the features which pointed away from the hotel room being a dwelling while focusing entirely (and not just principally) on what the guest generally did when she was in a hotel room, rendered the summing up unfair.
The conviction was unsafe, the appeal allowed and the conviction quashed on that count of the indictment.
[1] R v Flack [2013] 2 Cr App R (S) 56 CA
[2] R v Crown Prosecution Service ex parte Hudson [2017]
[3] R v Massey [2001] EWCA Crim 531
[4] Uratemp Ventures Limited v Collins (Ap) [2001] UKHL 43 per Lord Millett

