skip to Main Content

Trust and the Rule of Law

It is, or should be, self-evident that trust and the rule of law go hand in hand. At a time when the country is subject to emergency legislation including rules and guidance that would, in ordinary times, be regarded as unduly restrictive or even draconian, it is even more important that we should be able to trust those responsible for making those rules and that everyone should be subject to, and abide by, the rule of law.

Professor Dicey in 1885 expressed the rule of law as being that no person is above the law, but every person whatever be his or her rank or condition is subject to the ordinary law of the realm and amenable to the jurisdiction of the ordinary tribunals. That means to say that no one is above the law and all are subject to the same law administered in the same courts. Even as long ago as 1733 Dr Thomas Fuller was saying “Be you never so high, the law is above you.”

It hardly needs underlining that when the country is in a form of lockdown, with many thousands unable to venture from their front doors, visit loved ones, attend dying relatives or even their funerals, it is more important than ever that the rule of law is seen to be observed by those who have had to suffer the most. If there appears to be one rule for them and another for us public trust is lost in a flash.

At present the situation with this wretched virus is easing but the battle is not yet won. It has eased because the vast majority of the general public have observed the law and followed the guidelines, but there have been cases where people in high places, close to government or within branches of it, have breached the rules and resigned because of it.

We are now in the throes of another such episode with a seemingly forced public explanation by someone who should not even be in the public eye, supported by a number of lame comments from Ministers of the Crown and a fumbling explanation from the Prime Minister himself. Opinion polls today demonstrate what little credibility attaches by the general public to those statements.

The danger is that people will now breach the law or advice because those in high places seem to be making it up as they go along. Perhaps some will, but I suspect, despite the comings and goings (and not goings) of recent events, most will not. Most, fortunately, have more sense than some of those in government or others in senior positions who treat the rest with apparent disdain. The message, therefore, in the absence of leadership, must be to continue to use the common sense that has got us this far and, as always, when the time comes exercise our power appropriately at the ballot box.

We may not always be able to trust politicians but we can trust the judges. The great law lord, Lord Bingham, expressed the core principle of the rule of law to be that all persons and all authorities within the state, whether public or private, should be bound by and entitled to the benefit of laws publicly made and administered in the courts. More than ever it is crucial that we follow these principles for, as the philosopher John Locke, stated in 1690, “Wherever law ends, tyranny begins.”

Back To Top